Tragedy and Close Calls: Central Florida Grapples With Back-to-Back School Bus Crashes
Guest Editorial by Barry Foster
Central Florida is reeling from a harrowing succession of school bus tragedies and accidents, as communities in Polk and Highlands counties grapple with back-to-back morning collisions that have left two families mourning and schools on high alert.
Polk County Devastation
The dark sequence began on Monday morning, Oct. 5, before sunrise on Lucerne Park Road (State Road 544) in Polk County. At approximately 6:15 a.m., a westbound white Chevrolet Malibu driven by 23-year-old Maria Jimenez crossed the double yellow center line for reasons still unknown to investigators.
The Malibu clipped the rear of an eastbound school bus carrying 37 Winter Haven High School students, its driver and her 9-year-old daughter. The violent impact tore off a bus tire and forced the vehicle into the westbound lane, triggering a catastrophic head-on collision with a silver Jeep.
The Jeep instantly caught fire, and the bus overturned onto its roof. A fourth vehicle, a Kia Forte, subsequently struck the Malibu from behind, though its driver escaped with minor injuries.
The human toll was devastating. Adinaluz Prieto Oyola, a 16-year-old sophomore and aspiring cheerleader, lost her life on what was supposed to be her first day of practice. Deshawn Smith, a 26-year-old motorist commuting to work in the silver Jeep, was killed instantly.
Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd noted that Smith had no opportunity to avoid the sudden impact.
Amidst the horror, heroism emerged. Bus driver Jessica Dye, 34, who was driving under the speed limit and cleared of any wrongdoing, freed herself after being pinned inside and immediately began pulling children from the wreckage.
Officials also commended students who showed extraordinary bravery, including a young man captured on video comforting Prieto Oyola and promising he wouldn’t leave her side.
While three students remained hospitalized in stable condition by Tuesday morning and dozens were evaluated, AdventHealth Heart of Florida treated and discharged 10 young patients to their parents.
Sheriff Judd reported that Jimenez cooperated fully with a voluntary blood draw and phone inspection, showing no initial signs of impairment or phone use, though traffic citations remain likely as the National Transportation Safety Board opens a separate safety investigation.
The Highlands County Close Call
Just 24 hours later, the region faced another heart-stopping alert just across county lines.
On Tuesday morning, Oct. 6, at approximately 7:33 a.m., 11 students narrowly escaped serious injury in a multi-vehicle crash at the intersection of U.S. Highway 27 and Gould Road East in Highlands County.
According to the Florida Highway Patrol, a Volvo semi-truck traveling northbound on U.S. 27 failed to stop in time, slamming into the rear of a Hino box truck that was stopped in the left lane. The violent impact redirected the box truck into the right lane, where its front side swiped a school bus driven by a 69-year-old Lake Placid woman.
The bus was stationary in the right lane with its flashing red lights and warning equipment fully engaged.
Miraculously, all 11 juvenile passengers and the drivers involved were wearing seat belts. While the drivers of all three vehicles sustained minor injuries, only two students required minor medical treatment at the scene before being released.
State Trooper R. Haggard and the FHP are actively investigating the chain-reaction crash.
Community Resilience
With two communities shaken in less than 48 hours, school districts and state leaders have mobilized support systems. Grief counselors remain available at Winter Haven High School, while Gov. Ron DeSantis’ office has offered state resources.

Truly Local news. Truly Polk County.
Your community. Your news. Your right to know. Follow The Citrus Tea News for real local news across Polk County, and subscribe to our free e-Weekly newsletter at the links below. We welcome your comments and questions. Send us a message to reach our team.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happened in the Winter Haven school bus crash?
Around 6:15 a.m. on Monday, Oct. 5, 2026, a westbound Chevrolet Malibu crossed the double yellow line on Lucerne Park Road (State Road 544) and struck the rear of an eastbound Polk County Public Schools bus carrying 37 Winter Haven High School students, the driver and her 9-year-old daughter. The bus was pushed into the westbound lane, hit a Jeep head-on and overturned into a ditch. A Kia Forte also struck the Malibu.
Who died in the Polk County school bus crash?
The Polk County Sheriff’s Office identified the victims as Adinaluz Prieto Oyola, 16, a Winter Haven High School sophomore, and Deshawn Smith, 26, of Haines City, who was driving the Jeep.
Will the Malibu driver face charges in the Winter Haven bus crash?
Sheriff Grady Judd said no criminal charges were expected as of Oct. 6 and that the driver, 23-year-old nursing student Maria Mondragon Jimenez of Haines City, would likely receive traffic citations. She gave a voluntary blood sample, and results were pending. The sheriff’s office and the National Transportation Safety Board are investigating.
Did the Winter Haven school bus have seat belts?
Yes. Polk County Public Schools said the bus was equipped with seat belts.
Was anyone hurt in the Highlands County school bus crash?
The Highlands County Sheriff’s Office said two students suffered minor injuries when a box truck clipped a stopped school bus at U.S. 27 and Gould Road in Venus shortly after 7:30 a.m. on Oct. 6. The bus was carrying students to Lake Placid High School and Lake Placid Middle School. The Florida Highway Patrol is investigating.
Sources: “Winter Haven School Bus Crash: Judd Says Malibu Veered,” The Citrus Tea News, thecitrustea.com, Oct. 5, 2026; “2 dead, multiple injured in school bus crash with children on board,” ABC News, abcnews.com, Oct. 6, 2026; “Two Killed, Dozens Injured in Polk County School Bus Crash Near Winter Haven,” Island of News Tampa Bay, iontb.com, Oct. 6, 2026; “Polk Sheriff: Winter Haven crash happened in a ‘blink of an eye’,” Spectrum Bay News 9, baynews9.com, Oct. 6, 2026; “‘She’s a hero’: Polk bus driver pinned in seat freed herself to help kids in deadly crash,” WFLA News Channel 8, wfla.com, Oct. 6, 2026; “Winter Haven student killed in bus crash identified as cheerleader: ‘An amazing young lady’,” WFLA News Channel 8, wfla.com, Oct. 6, 2026; “Winter Haven High School mourns 16-year-old killed in school bus crash,” WFLA News Channel 8, wfla.com, Oct. 7, 2026; “Winter Haven school bus crash: What caused 4-vehicle collision that killed 2 people?” WFLA News Channel 8, wfla.com, Oct. 7, 2026; “NTSB Investigates Fatal Florida School Bus Crash, Officials Praise Driver’s Response,” School Transportation News, stnonline.com, Oct. 7, 2026; “2 dead in school bus collision with SUV, Jeep, Polk County sheriff says,” WKMG News 6, clickorlando.com, Oct. 5, 2026; “How area hospitals coordinated response after deadly Winter Haven school bus crash,” Tampa Bay 28, tampabay28.com, Oct. 7, 2026; “School bus clipped by box truck in Highlands County crash on US 27: HCSO,” FOX 13 Tampa Bay, fox13news.com, Oct. 6, 2026; “2 students injured in Highlands County school bus crash,” 10 Tampa Bay, wtsp.com, Oct. 6, 2026; “Two students injured in Highlands County school bus crash: HCSO,” Tampa Bay 28, tampabay28.com, Oct. 6, 2026

