Real estate agent Karen Guffey speaks at the lectern during the Nov. 16, 2026, Bartow City Commission meeting.
· · ·

Bartow CRA Takes Up S&P Mobile Home Park Purchase Dec. 2 After Real Estate Agents Object

A proposed approval and ratification of a contract to purchase the S&P Mobile Home Park at the asking price of $9 million ($720,000 per acre, for 12.5 acres) was challenged at the Nov. 16 Bartow City Commission meeting by three real estate agents, two who spoke before commissioners, with the third yielding her three-minute time to one of the other two.

Originally listed on the consent agenda, both James Clements and Karen Guffey, real estate agents, requested it be moved to Other Commission Business – New Business. They were not the only ones making the request, as Vice Mayor Laura Simpson stated she had intended to propose that be done.

Guffey began, stating that it was her (and others’) understanding that while an appraisal had yet to be done, she questioned the purpose.

“An appraisal will not change the price if it goes lower or higher,” she said. This was because it had earlier been made known that the owner was not going to negotiate.

She then offered two comparisons from recent transactions, one of those being that the developer of the Stuart Crossing Apartments paid $3 million for 147.7 acres, a cost of $20,300 per acre. The other comparison was that of the commercial property across from Bartow Ford on U.S. 98, where a retail park is slated: 40.59 acres at a cost of $14,358,000, or $353,732 per acre. Both, she said, were comparable to the mobile park.

From there, Guffey queried what was to be gained and/or lost.

“The intent of the city per the documents and agenda package is to have a vacant parcel that will be marketed to developers,” she said. “The hope is that the purchase price may be recouped, either in the front end from a redevelopment partner, or through the form of increased tax revenue, and increment. Taking this piece of property off the tax rolls right now is a loss of about $45,000.”

She summed it up, asking rhetorically if her understanding was correct.

James Clements urges city commissioners, who also serve as the CRA board, to reconsider going forward with a proposed purchase of the S&P Mobile Home Park. Photo by Steve Steiner.

Clements then followed, starting with the fact that the city/CRA had entered into discussion prior to the passage of Amendment 3, which will significantly reduce tax revenue due to a higher homestead rebate, and he urged against it.

“For that reason alone, and the unknown of what the city’s budget, the CRA’s budget is going to look like in the future,” he said. “I think by following through on this it would create a legacy of hardship for the city for many years.”

He, too, questioned, as had Guffey, what was to be achieved by having an appraisal. As an example, he recently helped a relative in the negotiation with the city in which two appraisals were performed that led to an agreed price in the middle of the two appraisals. So, why, then, he asked, is the city willing to give the mobile park owner the asking price.

Clements stated he held no qualms over the purpose of the CRA’s interest in the property.

“I understand the CRA’s idea is to, or, their quest is to eliminate blight in the city, and that is certainly a blighted area,” Clements said. “Buying it without a binding appraisal, completed, is, in my opinion, just not the right thing to do.”

He also raised the specter of liability following an environmental study and cleanup that might need to be done. Then he expressed concern about the role the city would need to fulfill should the purchase go through.

“The City of Bartow also does not need to be a landlord to 100-plus mobile homes,” he said. Then, because Commissioner Gary Ball was absent, Clements stated that further discussion should include the missing commissioner. Then he touched upon the projected loss of $45,000 if the sale were to go through. “Again, at a time post-Amendment 3 that we really don’t have $45,000 to give.

“So, if you approve this item tonight, or at another meeting, it will be a years-long, in my opinion, the culmination of one commissioner’s ambition to rid herself of what is admittedly a blight to her property. This blight is supposed to be what CRA is to eliminate, but not at the cost it is proposed.”

Clements added that in talking with county officials, they termed the proposal as “insanity” and that they would not pay that much. In fact, he said he had been told the county had been offered the property a number of years back for $5 million, and the county turned it down.

He acknowledged he wasn’t sure whether what he had been told was accurate, which is where City Manager Mike Herr interjected.

“Who did you say wanted to buy the property?” Herr asked.

“I said it was offered, supposedly to the county,” responded Clements. When Herr asked when this supposedly took place, Clements said he didn’t have a timeline. “But I would have thought, with as much money as the county had, I mean, they’re pretty tight with their funds …”

“But it didn’t happen,” shot back Herr, to which Clements concurred, stating that it was because they (being the county) thought it was too much at that time.

“The just market value, according to Neil Combee, is $2.818 million, or $225,000 an acre, and the assessed value is only $1.924 million, which is $153,900 per acre,” said Clements. “So, I urge you to vote against this, and let’s start over and try another way.”

Commissioners, who also serve as the CRA board, agreed to take up the matter at the CRA board’s Dec. 2 meeting.

(Reporter’s Notebook: [HOLD FOR BECKY: review note 2] The commissioner whose property borders the S&P Mobile Home Park is Trish Pfeiffer. It is the site of Simply Storage, 800 W. Main St. [END HOLD]

City Manager Mike Herr is a former Polk County manager.

Neil Combee heads the Polk County Property Appraiser office. He is a former county commissioner, as well as having served in the Florida House of Representatives, from which he later resigned to take a position with the U.S. Department of Agriculture.)

Steve Steiner can be reached at [email protected].

This is what local journalism looks like. Follow The Citrus Tea News for more Polk County coverage, or subscribe to The Citrus Tea News e-Weekly at the link in our bio.

citrus tea news logo

Truly Local news. Truly Polk County.

Your community. Your news. Your right to know. Follow The Citrus Tea News for real local news across Polk County, and subscribe to our free e-Weekly newsletter at the links below. We welcome your comments and questions. Send us a message to reach our team.

SubSCRIBE For free FOLLOW ON FACEBOOK CONTACT US

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is Bartow paying for the S&P Mobile Home Park?
The contract price is $9 million for about 12.5 acres, or about $720,000 an acre, according to the Nov. 16 agenda packet.

What is the S&P Mobile Home Park worth on the tax rolls?
The Polk County Property Appraiser lists a 2026 just market value of $2,818,168 and an assessed value of $1,924,255.

When will Bartow decide on the purchase?
Commissioners, sitting as the CRA board, agreed to take it up at the CRA’s Dec. 2, 2026, meeting.


Sources: “Regular Meeting Agenda,” City of Bartow City Commission, cityofbartow.net, Nov. 16, 2026; “Regular Meeting Minutes,” City of Bartow City Commission, cityofbartow.net, Oct. 19, 2026.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *